ROLE #3
The Local Anchor
Role Summary
Think about all the different ways that you spend money in the community right now. On physical space. On vendors. On programming for students. On transportation. Beyond that, think about how often you leverage your “institutional capital” to create business opportunities – like allowing students to use their dining dollars at a local restaurant or entering into a research partnership with a business.
Being a local anchor means creating a comprehensive strategy around how you use your existing spend and resources – and how you could leverage new spend and resource commitments – to support local investment opportunities.
Summary of Benefits
Of all the roles discussed in this Roadmap, being a local anchor might be the clearest path to creating financeable opportunities. If you can leverage institutional dollars or resources to provide direct or indirect backing for local deals, you’ll ensure they happen without spending the hundreds of hours you’d otherwise spend in staff time as an Opportunity Sponsor, a Capacity Builder, or a Capital Aggregator. And it may be the most time-efficient and cost-efficient means to create financeable opportunities if you can be creative about redirecting your existing spending.
Financial & Resource Commitment
FINANCIAL COMMITMENT
RESOURCE COMMITMENT
Being a local anchor means leveraging either a financial commitment or a resource commitment to “make a market.” You’ve got two ways as an institution to make that market – directly, through your spending, and indirectly, through the activities, projects, and businesses you endorse / use your resources to back.
Going down either path can involve either (1) redirecting existing spend or resource allocations or (2) creating new spend or resource allocations. That’s why the spreads on the chart above are so much broader for this role than for others. Depending on your strategy, you could elect to spend more dollars with local minority-led businesses or commit new balance sheet dollars to paying the lease for a local business incubator.
Functional Scope / Workflow
There are four big “buckets” in which you can play an anchor support role:
BUCKET 01
Backing Physical Space Development
Space – Signing Long-Term Leases and Rent Guarantees
Imagine two off-campus historic rehabilitation deals with identical deal profiles and identical returns – but in one, the building is a credit-quality commercial tenant, and the other is a startup nonprofit organization. Even though both deals look the same, the latter is far riskier than the former – so investors will discount the return profile accordingly and choose the former over the latter almost every time. If a college or university is willing to place itself “on the hook” for those rent payments (either directly – by signing the lease – or indirectly – by guaranteeing the nonprofit’s lease payments), investors will look at the credit quality of the institution, not the nonprofit – and a deal gets done that might never have otherwise closed. Your tangible action steps, then, can be:
- Entering into LOIs or full lease agreements to master-lease space within real estate developments you want to support. That space can then be used for university purposes (e.g., graduate student housing) or subleased to a third party for community purposes (e.g., a business incubator or childcare center).
- Signing onto an existing lease or LOI as a guarantor. This route involves less up-front financial commitment (you’ll only be called to honor the guarantee if the tenant cannot pay), and is best suited for developments where the tenants have the ability to pay their own way (e.g., a coworking space, grocery store, or other potentially cash-positive operation).
BUCKET 02
Leveraging the Procurement Process
Vendors – Preferred Procurement and Purchase Orders
Imagine two pre-revenue biotech companies raising equity, both with similar growth patterns, leadership teams, and intellectual property – but one has a 3-year service contract with a university hospital, and the other does not. Investors flock towards companies they know will get repeat business (thanks to preferred procurement status) from credit-quality institutions. Pre-sales, purchase orders, contracts, and other indicators all help prove the validity of a business concept (although hard sales are always the best indicator!). To take tangible action on this step, you can:
- Establish a preferred contractor or service provider program that prioritizes diverse, community-centric businesses – then make it as easy as possible for the people in that pipeline to do business with you (typically by signing long-term contracts with them and putting them first on bid lists, etc.).
- Enter into a set, long-term contract or procurement relationship with those same businesses that make it through your pipeline.
- Provide technical assistance and support services as a Capacity Builder (business planning assistance, etc.) needed to help those vendors/procurement partners continue to grow.
BUCKET 03
Facilitating Access to Capital
Access to Capital
Both the Space and Vendor examples above pre-suppose that the development firm (for space) and the vendor (for procurement) have or can get access to the capital they’ll need to complete the development and satisfy the contract. That might not always be the case, particularly if those developers are from underrepresented groups or if the suppliers are minority/women owned business enterprises. If you have a large number of suppliers you’re supporting that lack access to capital, consider building a pipeline of those suppliers and being a Capital Aggregator for them (either using your own endowment dollars to make revolving loans or by finding third parties who want to invest).
BUCKET 04
Creating Programmatic Relationships
Reputational Support / Indirect Assistance
Thus far, the ideas provided have mostly involved your institution spending its dollars to create places and improve businesses locally. There are other, indirect ways that institutions can leverage their reputations, their faculty, and even their students to provide financial assistance to community-oriented development. These include:
- Housing Partnerships: Add a residential real estate project undertaken by a minority development firm using MWBE contractors and suppliers to a preferred off-campus housing list, then leverage student housing or affairs to drive traffic there.
- “Dining Dollars” / Student Spend Partnerships: Let students spend on-campus meal plans or other controlled pools of funds within certain designated establishments (real estate or businesses).
- Programming Partnerships: Run university programming (e.g., workforce development, student social events, etc.) or develop programming partnerships with off-campus facilities owned or developed by minority / underrepresented groups (to drive students or other traffic there).
- Research Partnerships: Enter into an MOU or other arrangement with an operating business (hopefully a MWBE) that allows it to say it is jointly working on a project with your institution to customers / potential investors. Your name associated with the business may help those businesses close deals that lead to new revenue opportunities.
Related Case Studies
Arizona State
Phoenix, AZ
Similarities: Local Anchor
Arizona State moved its schools of nursing and journalism and other programs into a once-blighted section of Phoenix in a project that includes student housing and private development. Part of the anchor institution model is to invest in a suite of different programs and initiatives meant to connect them with the community.
Bates College
Lewiston, ME
Similarities: Local Anchor
Boston-based Arctaris is building workforce housing and broadband infrastructure across Maine.(Source: Beeck Center) One of their projects is on Bates College’s campus to provide workforce housing for Bates’ employees.
California State University, Dominguez Hills
Carson, CA
Similarities: Local Anchor
The university is working with energy storage firm Stem, Inc. to implement the company’s software-driven energy storage service to drive down energy costs across the university. “CSU Dominguez Hills is another example of a higher education leader who seeks Stem’s automated energy savings while also contributing to more intelligent grid solutions,” said John Carrington, CEO of Stem. “California’s universities and colleges want energy storage to help them control their energy choices, play a strong role in their community, and help transition the state to even higher amounts of renewable energy.”
Case Western Reserve in Cleveland
Cleveland, OH
Similarities: Local Anchor
The Greater University Circle Initiative coordinates three large anchor institutions located in Cleveland’s University Circle area—about one-square mile of educational, cultural, and health institutions. Through this initiative, the Cleveland Clinic, University Hospitals, and Case Western Reserve University networked and deployed their resources in a powerful challenge to the persistent poverty and disinvestment in seven surrounding neighborhoods.
Clemson University
Clemson, SC
Similarities: Local Anchor
Clemson University has deployed a distributed energy storage system in an effort to reduce energy costs and to provide engineering students an opportunity to practice measuring and tracking energy savings. “Our distributed energy storage system is a natural extension of our core businesses in the buildings and battery markets and partnering with Clemson University allows us to help deliver the kind of smart and integrated energy management that will keep students and faculty comfortable while driving down utility costs,” said John Schaaf, vice president of distributed energy storage at Johnson Controls, in a prepared statement.
College of St. Joseph
Rutland, VT
Similarities: Local Anchor
St. Joseph’s accreditation was suspended in 2019 because of financial concerns. Now, the college’s space and land is being evaluated for potentially becoming an innovation center for the surrounding community.
Deep South Economic Mobility Collaborative (Multiple HBCUs)
Southeast
Similarities: Local Anchor
Hope Enterprise Corporation, with a commitment from Goldman Sachs, partnered with seven cities and nine historically Black colleges and universities to launch the Deep South Economic Mobility Collaborative (DSEMC). These include Alabama State University, Miles College, Philander Smith College, Southern University and A&M College, Dillard University, Xavier University of Louisiana, Jackson State University, Tougaloo College, and LeMoyne-Owen College.
Drexel University
Philadelphia, PA
Similarities: Local Anchor
The Lindy Institute for Urban Innovation’s Nowak Metro Finance Lab, advances thought leadership, research, as well as new resources and tools to build support for communities leveraging Opportunity Zones.”
Duke University
Durham, NC
Similarities: Local Anchor
Hope Enterprise Corporation, with a commitment from Goldman Sachs, partnered with seven cities and nine historically Black colleges and universities to launch the Deep South Economic Mobility Collaborative (DSEMC). These include Alabama State University, Miles College, Philander Smith College, Southern University and A&M College, Dillard University, Xavier University of Louisiana, Jackson State University, Tougaloo College, and LeMoyne-Owen College.
Howard University
Washington, D.C.
Similarities: Local Anchor
Howard University teamed up with the Washington, D.C. government, Fannie Mae, and corporate partners to transform 45 abandoned, university-owned properties in a neglected neighborhood into more than 300 housing units and $65 million in commercial development. The Howard University LeDroit Park Initiative had three themes: 1) celebrate the history of the area; 2) redefine the community; and 3) enhance the quality of life and safety.
Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis
Indianapolis, IN
Similarities: Local Anchor
IUPUI hosts a class called “Planning for a Profitable Business” in a borrowed corner of a public housing complex for formerly homeless veterans on Indianapolis’ Near West Side. The students are current and aspiring entrepreneurs, many of them from this hard-luck neighborhood, which IUPUI is working to improve.”
Kansas State University
Manhattan, KS
Similarities: Local Anchor
In 2006, Kansas State held listening sessions across the state aimed at identifying challenges facing rural Kansas communities. During these sessions, the need to support rural grocery stores rose to the top.
LaSalle University
Philadelphia, PA
Similarities: Local Anchor
In 2004, La Salle University’s Office of Community and Economic Development worked with leadership and community members to craft a realistic plan to improve the quality of life for residents around the campus. The University’s findings led them to The Reinvestment Fund (TRF), a Philadelphia-based CDFI and leader in the financing of neighborhood revitalization, affordable housing, community facilities, supermarkets, and commercial real estate.
Marquette University
Milwaukee, WI
Similarities: Local Anchor
Marquette University is one of the 5 anchor institutions funding the Near West Side Partners nonprofit organization. The organization’s mission is to revitalize and sustain the Near West Side as a thriving business and residential corridor, through collaborative efforts to promote economic development, improved housing, unified neighborhood identity and branding, and greater safety for residents and businesses.
Ohio University
Athens, OH
Similarities: Local Anchor
Ohio University is very active in community development throughout Appalachian Ohio. They work with a network of regional entrepreneurship partners including a business incubator they run, an Angel Fund, a public VC Fund, several non-profit development orgs, and are very engaged in OZ work in Southern Ohio.
Rowan University
Glassboro, NJ
Similarities: Local Anchor
As Rowan began to increase its capital spending locally, the city of Glassboro saw a unique opportunity to leverage the Rowan investments by developing a plan for the transformation of the downtown area leading to the university. This plan ultimately became the $476 million, mixed-use development of Rowan Boulevard. In the city of Glassboro more than 30 percent of school-aged children qualified for the free lunch program and 20 percent of families earn under the poverty line.
Rutgers University – Newark
Newark, NJ
Similarities: Local Anchor
The Center for Urban Entrepreneurship & Economic Development (CUEED) at RU-N is one of the first centers of its kind to integrate scholarly works with private capital, government, and non-profit sectors to develop citywide resources and bring renewed economic growth and vitality through urban entrepreneurship.
Tulane
New Orleans, LA
Similarities: Local Anchor
The Warwick Hotel has been abandoned since Hurricane Katrina. The 154 room hotel, with its 1950s-era modernist architecture, opened in 1952. Tulane University signed a lease on Warwick and the structure will be completely renovated using opportunity zone money from the New Orleans Redevelopment Fund.
UAB
Birmingham, AL
Similarities: Local Anchor
The University of Alabama at Birmingham offers assistance to full-time, benefits-eligible faculty and staff who buy or renovate a home in designated areas in the nearby neighborhoods of Five Points, Glen Iris and North and South Titusville. These five year conditional grants may be used for the purchase, down payment and/or closing costs for a new home or for renovations on an existing home in the incentive zone.
University at Buffalo
Buffalo, NY
Similarities: Local Anchor
To encourage home ownership and help support stabilization and revitalization in and around the South Campus, the University at Buffalo offers the UB H.O.M.E. (Home Ownership Made Easy) program to full-time and part-time faculty and staff. This program is being funded by the University at Buffalo Foundation (UBF) in partnership with West Side Neighborhood Housing Services (West Side NHS), Inc., a NeighborWorks America Chartered Member with a proven track record of housing and community revitalization.
University of Chicago (Housing)
Chicago, IL
Similarities: Local Anchor
“Since the University of Chicago launched its employer-assisted housing program in 2003, it has had 230 employees receive assistance to purchase homes in Woodlawn, North Kenwood, South Shore, Washington Park, and a few other nearby neighborhoods.”
University of Dayton
Dayton, OH
Similarities: Local Anchor
The university serves as an anchor in The Dayton Arcade project which restored a 9-building complex in downtown Dayton. The projectincludes affordable and market-rate units, University of Dayton and the Entrepreneurs Center’s Arcade Innovation Hub, leasable office and retail space, and event space. The Arcade is part of a larger plan by the City of Dayton to bring residents, jobs, and visitors back to the downtown.
University of Iowa
Iowa City, IA
Similarities: Local Anchor
“Hannon Armstrong joins ENGIE and Meridiam in the “Hawkeye Energy Collaborative,” which was awarded a $1 billion 50-year utility management concession contract in December 2019 and reached financial close on March 10, 2020. Hawkeye Energy Collaborative will support the University of Iowa’s energy, water, and sustainability goals for two campuses spanning 1,700 acres in Iowa City, Iowa. Under the agreement, ENGIE will operate, maintain, optimize, and improve the on-campus utility systems for the University.
University of Memphis
Memphis, TN
Similarities: Local Anchor
University Neighborhoods Development Corporation works to build and enrich campus and community environment by investing in surrounding neighborhoods. UNDC is a partnership between University of Memphis, University District Business Alliance, University District, Inc., Shelby County Division of Planning and Development, and Economic Development Growth Engine. Opportunity zones are one of their main initiatives. Their Work Local program is designed to improve the community through job access and blight reduction by providing job-seeking panhandlers with a day’s wages and a meal to clean-up sites, where they work to reduce urban blight.
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, PA
Similarities: Local Anchor
Between 1996 and 2003, the University of Pennsylvania tripled the dollar amount of goods and services purchased from West Philadelphia businesses through their Economic Inclusion Initiative. They continue to focus on local purchasing and aim to award 20 percent of all construction contracts to minority or women-owned businesses.
University of Virginia’s College at Wise
Wise, VA
Similarities: Local Anchor
UVA-Wise is the lead partner for an Opportunity Appalachia program in the State. They are a leader in Southwest Virginia in community and economic development, with tremendous connections to community leaders across the region and to state government. They have a strong track record in downtown development and rural entrepreneurship efforts in +20 communities.
Related Resources
- Accelerator for America: Investor Prospectus Template
- Accelerator for America: Opportunity Zone Prospectuses
- Anchorage Land Trust
- B Analytics
- B-Corp Assessment
- B.World Platform: Impact Management & Measurement
- Baltimore Development Corporation: Opportunity Zones
- Citi CityBuilder
- City of Stockton: Opportunity Zones
- Community Investment Trust
- Community-Wealth: Community Development Corporations
- CSH: Thrive Framework for Improving Lives, Fostering Equitable & Inclusive Communities, Transforming Systems
- DIY Toolkit: Theory of Change Template
- East Bay Permanent Real Estate Cooperative
- East Portland CIT
- East Portland CIT Case Study
- Economic Innovation Group: Distressed Communities Index
- Economic Opportunity Plan Sample
- Economic Opportunity Plan Template
- Freeing Energy Project Directory of Cleantech Funds
- Future-Fit Business: Benchmarks
- GIIRS Funds
- Global Impact Investing Network: IRIS+ Metrics
- Housing Partnership Equity Trust
- Impact Management Project: Impact Management Norms
- Impact Management Project: Investment Measurement
- IMPLAN
- Inclusive Growth Score (MasterCard Center for Inclusive Growth)
- Invest Atlanta
- IRR (Impact Rate of Return)
- Kensington Corridor Trust
- Kevin T Payne Top 25 VC Firms Investing in MWBE
- LISC Community Partners OZ Playbook
- National Alliance of Community Economic Development Associations
- NICO Neighborhood REIT
- Opportunity Finance Network Higher Ed and CDFIs Working Together
- Opportunity Zones Reporting Framework (US Impact Investing Alliance, Beeck Center for Social Impact + Innovation, and the Federal Reserve Bank of New York)
- PolicyMap
- Purpose: Overview
- ROC NH
- ROC USA
- Shift Capital
- Shift Capital: Equitable Development Theory of Change
- Shift Capital: Impact Appraisal
- Social Value Investing
- SOPACT: Theory of Change Resources
- The B Impact Score
- The Beeck Center at Georgetown University
- The Opportunity Exchange
- The Ujima Project
- Transform Finance: Grassroots Community Engaged Investment
- Transform Finance: Grassroots Community Engaged Investment Whitepaper
- Trust Neighborhoods
- U.S. News & World Report: Why Colleges & Universities Should Embrace Opportunity Zones
- United Nations Sustainable Development Goals
- United Nations Sustainable Development Goals: Targets
- Urban Institute: Opportunity Zone Community Impact Assessment Tool Scorecard
- User-Centered Policy Making
- W.K. Kellogg Foundation: Step-by-Step Guide to Evaluation